FCC directs LDA to stop ‘frivolous litigation’ against family of martyred national hero Rashid Minhas
AI Summary
Pakistan’s Federal Constitutional Court rebuked the Lahore Development Authority for pursuing prolonged litigation against the family of fallen air force pilot Rashid Minhas over a Lahore property dispute. The court upheld earlier rulings in favor of Minhas’s brother and directed the authority not to waste public resources on frivolous cases.
ISLAMABAD: The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) has strongly rebuked the Lahore Development Authority (LDA) for prolonging the agony of the family of Pakistan Air Force (PAF) Pilot Officer Rashid Minhas Shaheed, recipient of the country’s highest military gallantry award, Nishan-i-Haider, and directed the authority not to squander its resources and public money on “frivolous, vexatious and obnoxious” litigation against individuals. The observation came in a judgment authored by Justice Ali Baqar Najafi, who regretted that the LDA had continued to drag the family of the martyred officer into litigation over a property dispute. “The family is facing the agony perpetuated by the LDA by dragging them in the courts in frivolous litigation,” the judge observed in the judgment released on Tuesday. Justice Najafi was heading a three-member FCC bench, also comprising Justice Rozi Khan Barrech and Justice Syed Arshad Hussain Shah, which took up an appeal filed by the LDA director general against a March 5, 2018, Lahore High Court (LHC) judgment in favour of Farooq Minhas, the martyred pilot’s real brother. The controversy stemmed from a consent decree passed in favour of Farooq Minhas, the respondent, on May 7, 2005. During subsequent execution proceedings, the LDA objected, arguing that the 14-marla plot in Gulberg-III, Lahore, was evacuee property acquired by the authority for the development of the Gulberg-III scheme. It further maintained that its predecessor, the Lahore Improvement Trust (LIT), had paid the award amount to the custodian of evacuee property and taken physical possession of the land on Dec 24, 1955. The authority also contended that the property fell within the boundaries specified in a notification issued on Aug 6, 1953, and that the award announced by the Land Acquisition Collector on Oct 30, 1962, had been finalised. It argued that no exemption or adjustment had been granted to the respondent’s predecessors-in-interest, Nawab Mirza and Maqsooda Begum. The LDA further questioned Maqsooda Begum’s acquisition of the property through a sale deed dated March 7, 1976, from Nawab Mirza, son of Agha Muhammad Hussain. The latter had claimed ownership on the basis of Property Transfer Document (PTD) No. 213, issued by the Deputy Settlement Commissioner on June 8, 1966, four years after the award was announced on Oct 30, 1962. According to the authority, the transaction was against the policy. However, the FCC noted that the LDA’s objections had consistently been rejected by the executing court, the revisional court and the LHC. Justice Najafi observed that the appeal challenged concurrent findings of the three courts, which had dismissed the authority’s objections during the execution proceedings relating to the May 7, 2005 decree. The court noted that the earlier decisions and the decree had attained finality, particularly as the consent decree had been passed on the basis of the LDA’s own “no objection”. It further observed that a declaration had also been granted in favour of the legal heirs of Maqsooda Begum, while the objections raised under Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) were frivolous and beyond the scope of an executing court. The courts below had also rejected the LDA’s claim that the Central Government had transferred the evacuee portion of the land to the LIT through a notification issued on May 16, 1951, under Section 12 of the Pakistan (Administration of Evacuee Property) Ordinance, 1949. They observed that there was no evidence of such a transfer or of any payment having been made to the LIT or the custodian. The FCC also referred to an Aug 17, 1980 decision of the Vigilance Commission, which stated that duly verified transfer orders would be honoured by the LDA and that only development charges would be recovered from the transferees. The authority had accepted and acted upon the decision, with its director general issuing the necessary directions. The LHC had consequently directed the LDA to stop claiming ownership of the disputed land, which had already become part of the Gulberg-III scheme, the FCC observed. The high court’s judgment was subsequently challenged by the LDA before the Supreme Court, which dismissed the petition, holding that the authority had no ownership rights over the land, as it had already been transferred by the Settlement Department to the occupants. The apex court had also found no reason to interfere with the LHC’s findings. “We, therefore, deem it appropriate that, instead of imposing costs, we direct the Director General, LDA, to ensure that the authority does not deplete its resources or public money on frivolous, vexatious and obnoxious litigation against individuals,” Justice Najafi observed. The FCC dismissed the LDA’s appeal, ruling that it was devoid of merit and refusing leave to appeal.